Copyright 2006 The Durham Herald Co.
The Herald-Sun (Durham, NC)
June 19, 2006 Monday
SECTION: EDITORIAL; Pg. A6
LENGTH: 506 words
HEADLINE: Hate crime, plain and simple
BYLINE: LEE D BAKER Guest Columnist
On June 6, Mary Few came home from work to find a cross burning in yard. The next day, she and her husband, Ed, discovered the letters KKK scrawled in red spray paint on the propane tank they use to fuel their modest home on Old Possum Road in Middlesex -- a small township of just over 800 people in Nash County.
The Fews are African American and they believe they are victims of racial terror and intimidation and want the incidents investigated as a hate crime. Middlesex Police Chief Charles Ferrell, however, believes the incidents do not constitute hate crimes, because they were motivated by simple animus and therefore they were "larceny and a few other weird things," not a hate crime. He may be right, technically. According to North Carolina law, a person can be prosecuted under the Ethnic Intimidation statute when the perpetrator commits an act against a person or their property because of "race, color, religion, nationality, or country of origin." Apparently, the harassment and intimidation experienced by the Fews was committed because Ed Few refused to sell his 1974 Corvette for $1,200. According to Ed Few, the harassment and intimidation began after he refused to sell his car, the phone calls continued with racial epithets and threats that caller would make Ed Few wish he had sold him that car. Chief Ferrell vows that he and his officers are pursuing this case aggressively, but he also acknowledges that the Few family has not been totally cooperative.
In some respects, not pursuing these incidents as a hate crime is similar to not prosecuting Mohammed Taheri-azar as a terrorist after he used a Jeep Grand Cherokee to plow over a crowd of students at UNC Chapel Hill last March because he wanted to "punish the government of the United States for [its] actions around the world." In both cases, the law precludes common sense. However, it appears that Police Chief Ferrell has no sense at all. In an interview with WRAL, he told a reporter, "at this point in time, I'm not ready to rule this as a hate crime. I'm thinking this is more of a grudge or some kind of personal vendetta-type thing," after all, "it was not your true shape of a cross, it was more like a capital 'T'."
North Carolina has a history of terrorism, much of it racially motivated. In the wake of recent findings by the 1898 Wilmington Race Riot Commission and the Greensboro Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the history of violence and terror in our state is particularly raw. Whatever the original motive of the harassment, once racial epithets are hurled, crosses or cross-like structures are set ablaze, and the letters KKK are used to deface a black family's property, a threshold is crossed and history is in play. It is not time to begin splitting legal hairs or making a distinction between lower and upper case letters. It is time to use common sense and stop the spread of hate crimes and terrorism in North Carolina.
Lee D. Baker is associate professor of Cultural anthropology and African American Studies at Duke University.
LOAD-DATE: June 21, 2006